Mechanical

Radio Transmitters Found in Canadian Coins

By now you may have seen the story about radio transmitters found in Canadian coins:

Each is virtually identical to the others, but the meat of the articles is:

Coins containing tiny transmitters have mysteriously turned up in the pockets of at least three American contractors who visited Canada, says a branch of the U.S. Defence Department.

There's an implication in the article that the U.S. Defense Security Service's report "Technology Collection Trends in the U.S. Defense Industry" is the source of this information, but it's not clear because the journalist didn't explain that bit very well.

That's not the only thing the journalist goofed up on: there's speculation in the articles (apparently from the journalist) that the idea is foolish because someone can merely drop the coin in a vending machine. This is not true. All you have to do is imperceptibly alter the weight of the coin and the Coke machine spits it back at you. You shrug and reach for another quarter.

Though the transmitter type is not named, the article further speculates that it might be an RFID tag. This seemed ridiculous due to the short range of transmission but according to a Wikipedia article on RFID:

Active [RFID] tags typically have much longer range [than passive tags] (approximately 300 feet) [and] the smallest active tags are about the size of a coin and sell for a few dollars.

Still, regardless of what's transmitting and how, nothing gets around the basic problem that these are coins. You're not going to have them for long so it seems like it should be easy to track their source: where did the contractors buy stuff in the past few days and receive change? Of course, if a pickpocket were to plant the coins (who's going to be surprised by a coin in their pocket?), that might fail. This also raises the question of how long a given coin tends to remain in an individual's possession, but I've no idea.

Whatever the transmitters are, they're short-ranged and a controlled environment seems best for them, but if you have the contractors in a controlled environment, why use coins at all? The implication is that it's presumed one can track the coins in an uncontrolled environment, but there's a lot of hand-waving there.

I doubt we'll hear more about this, but I'm quite intrigued.

  • Current Mood: curious curious
I didn't, since those seemed like reliable news sources. However, I just checked and I don't see any mention of it there. (I check snopes so often that I have a keyword search built into my browser for it :)
Wow, that would be sort of fun if it were true. I hadn't seen this yet.

...google news pointed me at: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070110.wspycoin0110/BNStory/National/home


"Spy coin report overblown, U.S. official says"

"But the item about the Canadian coins item appeared to be the result of only partial intelligence.

Defence contractors had apparently been give certain special-issue Canadian coins, the unfamiliar look of which caused them to be concerned about the money, a source said. That led to an investigation once the contractors returned to the United States .

But a U.S. agency that investigated the complaint found no evidence of any secret transmitters, or of any other tampering.

It's not clear why this information failed to find its way into the released U.S. Defence Security Service report."


Let the discussion of bi-governmental coverup commence. :)
Well, that's interesting. I didn't find that story, even though I searched for more information. However, it does solve one mystery. If you have a coin, what's to stop you from getting rid of it immediately? Well, if it's a commemorative coin, you'll keep it. Any why would a report about it carrying a transmitter pop up if there was no evidence of a transmitter?

Of course, since the entire idea is farfetched (and I think it is), then that explains why I was so confused about the idea.
Any why would a report about it carrying a transmitter pop up if there was no evidence of a transmitter?

I have some Iraqi WMD's I'd like to sell to you... dirt cheap, too! Comes with their own rolling trailer command centers.

Heh.